I Think I Shall Never See a Tree That Will Stay with Me


BEFORE and AFTER Removal of Ash Tree and Burning Bushes – 6/26/14
I had treated the ash tree for several years with imidacloprid.

I had treated the ash tree for several years with imidacloprid.

We’ve known for several years that the dreaded Emerald Ash Borer was headed to our area and it wanted our ash tree, the only large tree left on our lot. (We had a very large willow taken out of our backyard about 15 years ago.) I tried to hold it off as long as I could by treating it every May. However, this year about 3/4 of it failed to leaf out (see BEFORE picture above). Although we couldn’t spot any D-shaped holes, we knew our tree had succumbed to the Emerald Ash Borer.

Goodbye, ash tree!

Goodbye, ash tree!

The time came to take it down when neighbors down the street were having their ash cut down and the tree guys made an offer to cut ours, too. We asked them to take down the overgrown burning bushes as well, which were behind the hydrangeas in the bed behind the ash tree. The burning bushes had provided a nice leafy background (especially when they turned color in the fall!) to the left of our house, and along with the ash tree, they were the only plants that remained from the original front yard landscaping. However, as a master gardener I was aware of the problems with burning bush being invasive in our natural areas. Ours may not have been the worst culprit, but all the cultivars can be a problem so I’d already decided that we would have them taken out at the same time we had the ash cut down. In addition, my husband wanted them out of there so he could do some work around the foundation on that side of the house. After he is done, we will replace them with something else. (There are good suggestions for replacement here and elsewhere.)

The hostas have not fared well in full sun.

The hostas have not fared well in full sun.

Meanwhile, the shade garden on that side of the house suffered through the summer without shade. The hostas fared the worst. They got all bleached out and bug bitten. Over the next few years, while we’re waiting for the replacement tree to grow big enough to provide shade, I hope to plant large leafy annuals around them (perhaps castor bean plants) in an attempt to protect them from full afternoon sun.

As for replacing the ash tree, I wanted to go with a native species, and I asked Marcy Stewart-Pyziak, who had designed my front yard garden, for suggestions. (I certainly did not want to replace it with the same tree as everyone else–the tree guys were suggesting Sunset Maple. That would potentially set our area up for another loss of many trees at once if another species specific problem, such as the Emerald ASH Borer or Dutch ELM Disease, should hit.)  Then I looked up her suggestions on the Illinois Wildflowers and Possibility Place websites. I decided on a Chinquapin Oak (also spelled Chinkapin). Yesterday (9/12/14) I went to Possibility Place and picked out our new tree. Here it is!

Our New Tree (tagged with the green and white striped ribbon)

Our New Tree (tagged with the green and white striped ribbon)

 NEXT: Planting the New Tree


About A Well Watered Garden

Rea is my last name, and Chez Rea is what we call our home and family. That’s French for the Rea House, and it rhymes. Say “shay ray” and you’re pronouncing it right.
This entry was posted in Master Gardeners, Ornamentals. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to I Think I Shall Never See a Tree That Will Stay with Me

  1. I went ahead and published this post before planting the new tree because I’ve neglected this garden journal for too long. I’ve started writing other posts and certainly had many ideas for posts but have not actually published them here. Instead I’ve been posting pictures and a few quick updates on Facebook throughout the year. (My apologies to followers here who are not on Facebook, but it is the most convenient way to let most of my contacts know what is going on in the Chez Rea garden.) I am realizing the need to keep this blog updated for my own record keeping purposes as it is supposed to function as my garden journal, here I am. Hey, it’s a start!


  2. Pingback: A Warm Winter’s Tale | A Well Watered Garden

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s